NY
Suffolk
Shelter Island Heights
11964
5 Spring Garden Avenue
5 Spring Garden Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
Share Listing
Listing Type
Single Family
Listing Status
Active
29
$1,500,000

Home Details for 5 Spring Garden Avenue

Price
$1,500,000
Type
Residential
Bedrooms
5
Total Bathrooms
3
Full Bathrooms
2
Half Bathrooms
1
Square feet
2845
Year built
1880
Lot size acres
0.25
County
Suffolk
Total rooms
10
Basement
Full, Storage Space, Unfinished, Walk-Out Access
MLS Listing#
1004894
Hoa
448
Property Description

Dating back to the original 1871 layout of the Shelter Island Grove and Camp Meeting Association, Spring Garden Avenue is celebrated for its organic, rolling streetscapes and preserved 19th-century architecture. 5 Spring Garden Avenue is an authentic 1880 Victorian residence that embodies the classic style of the era, from its steeply pitched rooflines to its expansive exterior woodwork. The interior layout is expansive and true to its vintage, characterized by distinctive octagonal rooms on both the first and second floors. With five bedrooms, a sprawling third-floor attic loft, and a substantial footprint of covered decks and porches, the home offers a generous canvas within a historic setting. A significant structural update was completed in 2008, replacing the older foundation with a new poured concrete basement and structural footings, alongside the installation of a new roof. Featuring full access to the Shelter Island Heights Association tennis courts and beach club, this property represents an authentic piece of island history.

Property Features
  • Utilities
    • Natural Gas Available
    • Electricity Connected
    • Natural Gas Connected
    • Sewer Connected
    • Water Connected
  • Basement
    • Full
    • Storage Space
    • Unfinished
    • Walk-Out Access
  • House Interior
    • High Ceilings
    • Pantry
    • Soaking Tub
  • Cooling Information
    • Multi Units
  • Heating Information
    • Propane
  • Water Features
    • Public
  • Parking
    • Driveway
  • Fire Place
    • Family Room
School Information
School Information for 5 Spring Garden Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
Elementary School
Shelter Island School
Middle School
Shelter Island School
High School
Shelter Island School
Listing Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty - 631-749-1155
Presented by: Mackenzie Needham
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright ©2026 OneKey MLS. All Rights Reserved
Fair Housing Notice
Transportation
Check the walk, transit, and bike score for
Neighborhood Market Statistics
See average values in the proximity of this property
Median Listing Price
Median Days on Site
Median Square Feet
Market statistics compiled from data from OneKey MLS.
EXIT REALTY ISLAND ELITE
870 Love Lane, Mattituck, NY 11952
Office
631 937 5800
Request more details
Code: